Lily’s Kitchen vs Canagan: Which Suits Your Cat Better?
Both are UK premium darlings with named meat and no cereals — but they suit different cats, and the difference shows up in price per day and picky-cat acceptance.
Head to head
| Lily’s Kitchen | Canagan | |
|---|---|---|
| Meat content | 60–65% typical | 70–75% typical |
| Recipe style | Home-cooked feel, herbal additions | Biologically-appropriate, game-rich |
| Range | Wet + dry, kitten to senior | Mostly dry, some wet |
| Price per day (4 kg cat) | ≈ £0.90–1.20 | ≈ £1.20–1.60 |
| Fussy-cat record | Excellent — strong aroma | Good, drier texture divides opinion |
Our take
Sensitive or fussy cats often do best on Lily’s Kitchen for palatability; owners chasing maximum meat content lean Canagan. Many households run both — Canagan dry as the base, Lily’s wet for moisture and enthusiasm.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Lily’s Kitchen really grain-free?
The vast majority of the range is grain-free and complete; a few recipes contain brown rice — always check the specific product’s composition line.
Is Canagan worth the extra money?
If your cat thrives on very high meat content and you value 70%+ recipes, yes. Cats that do equally well at 60% meat may not justify the premium.
Which is better for kittens?
Both offer kitten-suitable complete recipes; Lily’s Kitchen has a dedicated kitten line, which makes portioning simpler through growth.
Can I mix the two brands?
Yes — mixing brands is fine if both are complete for the relevant life stage. Transition gradually as with any change.
